Asking a Living Person in a Form That Resembles Du‘ā’
Question: Clarify a matter for me. Du‘ā’ is an act of worship, but my question is: if a person asks a living person for something he is able to do, such as asking his father to bring him a shoe, then he says to his father, I supplicate you that you bring me the shoe, is this considered shirk? I know that asking a living person who is able for something that he is capable of is not shirk, but my question is: what if he asked him in the form of du‘ā’, while he is capable of doing it? I want to understand what is meant by “du‘ā’” that is worship.
Summary:
Final summary (very brief) Asking the living capable person in a normal linguistic form of du‘ā’: not shirk. Calling a created being with the worship-based du‘ā’: shirk. The difference is: does it include humility and deification and asking for what only Allah is able to do? Therefore it is allowed to call with the form of request from a created being with four conditions: He is living, and he is present, and he is capable, and one believes the one asked is only a means and Allah is the One who causes the result.
Answer:
In the name of Allah, all praise is due to Allah, and may Peace and Blessings be upon the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ)
This question is important, and it falls under the chapter of “distinguishing the worship-based du‘ā’ of request” from “an ordinary request from a living created being who is able”.
First: the meaning of du‘ā’ that is worship
Du‘ā’ is of two types according to the Salaf:
Du‘ā’ of worship (du‘ā’ of humility and submission)
It is the turning of the heart and limbs to Allah alone in request and desire and submission, with the belief that He alone is able to bring benefit and repel harm.
This type is not directed except to Allah, and directing it to other than Allah is major shirk.
Evidence: the saying of Allah,
From the Qur'an:
- 72:18
The places of worship are ˹only˺ for Allah, so do not invoke anyone besides Him.
From the Sunnah:
- Jami` at-Tirmidhi 2969An-Nu'man bin Bashir
from the Prophet (ﷺ) regarding Allah's saying: Your Lord said: Invoke Me, I shall respond to you (40:60, it appears that the author intended to apply it to Al-Baqarah 2:186). - he said: "The supplication is the worship." And he recited: 'Your Lord said: Invoke Me, I shall respond to you.' up to His saying: 'in humiliation.'"
(Narrated by the authors of the Sunan and authenticated by Shaykh al-Albānī)
From the Scholars:
- Ibn Taymiyyah said:
du‘ā’ includes the utmost humility to his Lord and the utmost need for Him, and this is not suitable except for Allah alone.
Du‘ā’ of request (asking for something) This includes that which is worship and that which is an ordinary permissible request. When is the du‘ā’ of request considered worship? If the request is from someone who none can fulfill except Allah, or it is in a form of humility and submission and deification. Such as: “O so-and-so, cure me.” “O my master, provide for me.” “Help me to have forgiveness for my sins.” This is shirk because it is asking for what only Allah is able to do. And when is it not worship? If the request is from a living, present, capable person in a natural way, without the meaning of worship. Such as: O my father, hand me the shoe. O my brother, help me. O Zayd, close the door. This is permissible by consensus. The Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) said: “Allah is in the aid of the servant as long as the servant is in the aid of his brother.” Second: does the request become shirk if a form of “du‘ā’” is used? If the son says to his father, “I supplicate you that you bring me the shoe.” Here we detail: The first case: if he intends by du‘ā’ an “ordinary request”: If he says “I supplicate you” or “I call upon you” intending I ask you, as the language is sometimes used. This is not shirk, rather it is speaking to people in their language. Evidence: usage of the Arabs The Arabs say: “I called upon so-and-so” meaning I called him and requested him. Allah said, “That you do not invoke anyone along with Allah,” meaning: do not request with worship and submission from anyone. But His saying, “So he called upon his Lord, indeed I am overpowered, so help me,” here it is the du‘ā’ of worship. So the term is shared, and the consideration is the meaning and intention. The second case: if he says it in a form that includes submission or worship: Such as saying to the father or the shaykh or the walī: “I plead with you that you provide for me.” “I seek rescue from you.” “I beseech you that you cure me.” “O my father, you are the one who controls my affair.” These are phrases of worship, and if said to a living, capable person they are prohibited, but they do not reach shirk except if they include asking for what is exclusive to Allah or submission of the heart. The third case: if he intends by du‘ā’ the “worship-based du‘ā’” that is directed habitually to Allah Meaning he says it in a form that is originally worship for Allah alone, such as saying to a living, capable person: “O Allah, O my father, give me the shoe.” Here he mixed between worship and calling. This is prohibited, and it reaches shirk if he believes that the created being deserves what Allah deserves. Third: summary of the answer Asking in the form of request from a living capable person is permissible. Whether he says, “Give me the shoe” or “I supplicate you to give me the shoe” if he intends the linguistic request. But if he intends by du‘ā’ worship and submission, this is not allowed. And if he asks the living person for healing or the unseen or forgiveness, or calls him with the call of worship, this is major shirk. Fourth: from the statements of the Salaf and scholars
From the Scholars:
- Ibn Taymiyyah:
whoever calls upon a created being with a call that includes the meaning of worship has committed shirk, and as for calling him or asking him for what he is able to do, this is not shirk.
From the Scholars:
- Ibn al-Qayyim:
du‘ā’ is of two types, du‘ā’ of request and du‘ā’ of worship.
What is from it for the created being in what he is able to do is permissible, and what is from what none can do except Allah is shirk.
From the Scholars:
- Al-Ṭabarī:
the meaning of “do not invoke anyone along with Allah” is do not request in a manner of worship and submission except from Him.
And Allah knows best.
← Back to Questions