Ruling on that Uses Impermissible Advertising
Question: السلام عليكم If I bought shares/owned a company/business that sells/produces products in a halal way, but it’s advertised with music (not in my control), then am I sinful? Context is I want to become part owner of a business but my relatives sell halal products through ads with music. I only want to buy/be involved in the halal part. I will kindly advise them too. They may also include tabarruj. بارك الله فيكم
Summary:
It is permissible for you to enter as a partner in this company if its activity is permissible in origin, and the existing violations are not predominant nor intended, while you object to them and do not approve of them. But if these prohibited advertisements are an essential part of the success of the business or the prohibited elements are predominant, then it is not permissible to enter, because it would be cooperation in sin.
Answer:
In the name of Allah, all praise is due to Allah, and may Peace and Blessings be upon the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ)
First, the basic legal principle
The basic principle in transactions is permissibility. Allah the Most High said
From the Qur'an:
- al Baqarah 275
"...But Allah has permitted trading and forbidden interest..."
So every business whose origin is permissible is allowed as long as it does not involve something prohibited as a dominant or intended element.
Second, the ruling on partnership when indirect violations exist If the company sells permissible products, but there are some prohibited elements, such as advertisements with music or improper display, then the ruling is detailed: 1. If the violations are: Incidental and not intended as the main purpose of the activity Not the main source of profit Not directly carried out by the partner And he does not approve of them, rather he objects and advises Then the basic ruling is permissibility, along with the obligation to object. The evidence is the statement of Allah,
From the Qur'an:
- al Maidah 2
"...Cooperate with one another in goodness and righteousness, and do not cooperate in sin and transgression..."
So if his involvement is not direct assistance in sin, rather his participation is in a permissible activity, along with his dislike of the wrongdoing and his effort to change it, then he does not fall under the prohibition.
2. If the violations are: Intended and inherent to the activity Or the business cannot operate without them, such as prohibited marketing being the basis of profit Or the prohibited elements are predominant in the company Then it is not permissible to enter it, because it is considered cooperation in sin. Third, statements of the scholars
From the Scholars:
- Ibn Taymiyyah said,
“If wealth contains both lawful and unlawful, it is permissible to take from it if it is not distinguished, and the lawful is predominant.”
- Ibn al Qayyim said,
“What is prohibited as a means may be permitted when there is a stronger need, if it is not intended.”
- Abd al Aziz ibn Baz said,
" If the foundation of the work is permissible, and some wrongdoing occurs in it, then it is obligatory to object, and that does not prevent the foundation of the work if it is not predominant."
- Muhammad ibn Salih al Uthaymin said,
“If a person does not directly engage in the prohibited matter nor approve of it, and it occurs from others, then he is not sinful, but he must object.”
Fourth, important conditions in this issue The following conditions must be met for permissibility: That the core activity is permissible That the violations are not intended and not predominant That his involvement is not direct assistance in the prohibited That he gives advice and objects That he strives, if possible, to reduce or change the wrongdoing
And Allah knows best.
← Back to Questions