How Can I Return Stolen Property After Repenting to Allah If the Store Has Closed and Its Owner Cannot Be Reached?
Question: As salam aleykum wa rahmatullah Some time ago, I stole some items from a store. Afterwards, I regretted what I had done and repented to Allah. However, in the meantime, the store permanently closed down. I would like to know how I can return what I owe, considering that the store no longer exists and its owner is no longer there.
Summary:
Repentance from theft is not fulfilled by repenting to Allah alone. Rather, the rights must be returned to their owners, because the rights of people are subject to strict accountability. If the store has closed, it is obligatory to search for its owner and attempt to reach him in order to return the stolen items or their value. It is not necessary to inform him of the theft; rather, it is permissible to deliver his rights to him through any reliable means. If the owner of the store cannot be reached after searching and investigating, the questioner should give the value of the stolen items in charity on his behalf, with the intention of fulfilling his right. If the rightful owner appears afterwards, he is given the choice between approving the charity or taking what is rightfully his. If his right is paid to him, the reward of the charity will belong to the questioner.
Answer:
First: Evidence from the Noble Quran
From the Qur'an:
- [Surah an-Nisa: 58]
"Indeed, Allah commands you to render trusts to whom they are due."
- [Surah ash-Shura: 25]
"And it is He who accepts repentance from His servants and pardons misdeeds."
Therefore, whoever steals property is obligated to repent sincerely to Allah and return the property to its owner, or return something equivalent to it if it is something that can be replaced with an equivalent, or its value if returning the original item or its equivalent is not possible.
Second: Evidence from the Prophetic Sunnah
From the Sunnah:
- Narrated by al-Bukhari.Abu Hurairah رضي الله عنه narrated that the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said:
"Whoever has wronged his brother concerning his honor or anything else, let him seek his forgiveness today, before there will be neither dinar nor dirham."
This indicates the obligation to free oneself from the injustices committed against others and to return their rights to them before the Day of Resurrection.
Third: Statements of the Scholars
From the Scholars:
- Shaykh Ibn Baz رحمه الله:
He was asked about a person who had stolen money, then repented and wished to return it to its owners. He explained that it is obligatory to return the money to its rightful owners through any possible means, even without disclosing the identity of the thief. He also clarified that it is not permissible to give the money in charity when it is possible to deliver it to its owners. However, if reaching them is not possible, the money should be given in charity on their behalf.
- Shaykh Ibn Uthaymeen رحمه الله:
He stated that whoever steals money is obligated to return it to its owner, even through indirect means. If the person does not know who the owner is or where he is located, it is permissible to give the money in charity on his behalf.
- The Permanent Committee for Scholarly Research and Ifta:
The Committee ruled that a thief is obligated to return stolen property to its rightful owners. If the owners or their heirs cannot be found, the stolen property should be given in charity on their behalf. If they appear afterwards, they are given the choice between accepting the charity or taking what is rightfully theirs.
Fourth: Applying the Ruling to the Questioner's Situation: -The questioner should search for the owner of the store through the available means, such as asking about him or searching for his previous contact information. -If he manages to reach the owner, he must return the stolen items or their value to him, without being required to inform him of what happened. -If the stolen items have already been consumed or used up, he must return their equivalent if possible, otherwise their value. -If he has forgotten the amount, he should strive to estimate it to the extent that he believes is most likely to clear him of his obligation. -However, if the owner of the store cannot be found after making the usual reasonable efforts, the questioner should give what is owed in charity to the poor on the owner's behalf. -Nevertheless, he remains liable for the amount if the owner later appears and demands his right. Conclusion: The closure of the store does not cancel the owner's right to the stolen property. Therefore, the questioner must sincerely repent, search for the rightful owner, and return the stolen items or their equivalent to him. If the owner cannot be reached after searching and investigating, the stolen items or their value should be given in charity on his behalf. If the owner appears afterwards and does not approve of the charity, his right must be paid to him. By doing so, the questioner will have followed the Islamically prescribed path of repentance and freeing himself from the rights owed to others.
And Allah knows best.
← Back to Questions