What Is the Islamic Ruling on Addressing Time and the Night in Poetry?
Question: السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته، حياك الله يا اخي الفضيل، There's a poem called 'O era of deadly silence', in which we find "يا زمن الصمت القاتل" and "يا ليل الحزن الثاقل", meaning they ask the night and the time. Also there's another poem which traces back to the time of Al Andalus and among the lyrics we find ' يا زمانا هل نسيت المسلما '. Is it shar3i to pronounce this kind of speech knowing it seem zaman refer to Allah? And if it were to refer to Allah what's the ruling (based on the hadith qudsi of Allah saying he is the time which the scholar explained) And in general does this kind of poem fall under the same rulling of the poem 'Ya taybah'? جزاك الله خيرا يوافق وكم الله ونسأل الله أن يزيدك علماً يا شيخنا
Summary:
The basic principle is that a Muslim should guard his tongue from expressions that could suggest incorrect beliefs regarding creed. If addressing the night or time is merely a well-known rhetorical style in the Arabic language, without believing that the night or time has any power, hears, or responds, then there is generally no harm in it, as it falls under the category of personification and rhetorical expression. However, if the intention is to attribute events to time itself, to object to Allah's decree, or to address time in a manner of blame and protest, then this falls under the prohibition mentioned in the Shariah, for which a severe warning has been reported. As for the claim that "time" in such expressions refers to Allah, this is incorrect. Allah is not time. Rather, He is the Creator and Controller of time, as the scholars explained regarding the Qudsi hadith. As for comparing such poems to Ya Taybah, this cannot be done categorically, because the ruling depends upon the intended meaning, not merely upon the fact that something is being addressed.
Answer:
In the name of Allah, all praise is due to Allah, and may peace and blessings be upon the Messenger of Allah ﷺ.
First: The Prohibition of Reviling Time
From the Sunnah:
- It is authentically reported in al-Bukhari and Muslim from Abu Hurayrah (may Allah be pleased with him) that the Prophet ﷺ said, narrating from his Lord:
"The son of Adam insults Me. He curses time, but I am time, for in My hand are the night and day.”
The Prophet ﷺ prohibited reviling time because Allah is ad-Dahr, meaning that Allah is the One who controls time and manages all that occurs within it. Whatever good or evil takes place during time occurs only by His decree. Thus, when a person reviles time while believing it to be the cause of what has happened, the reality of his revilement returns to Allah, the Creator and Controller of those events.
- And Abu Hurayrah (may Allah be pleased with him) reported that the Prophet ﷺ said, Allah, the Mighty and Majestic, said:
“The son of Adam abuses Me by reviling time, while I am ad-Dahr. In My Hand is the command. I alternate the night and the day.”
- In the narration of Muslim, the Prophet ﷺ said:
“None of you should revile time, for indeed Allah is ad-Dahr.”
From the Sunnah:
- In another narration recorded by Muslim, Allah says:
“The son of Adam hurts Me by saying: 'What a disappointment this time is!' So let none of you say: 'What a disappointment this time is,' for indeed I am ad-Dahr. I alternate its night and its day, and when I will, I shall take them away.”
- and in another narrationit is stated:
“None of you should revile time, for indeed Allah is ad-Dahr.”
This hadith does not mean that ad-Dahr is one of the Names of Allah, nor does it mean that Allah Himself is time. Rather, it means that Allah is the One who controls time and decrees whatever occurs within it.
From the Salaf:
- Al-Shafi'i, Abu 'Ubaydah, and others (may Allah have mercy on them) said regarding the Prophet's statement, "Do not revile time, for indeed Allah is ad-Dahr":
The Arabs during the pre-Islamic period, whenever hardship, calamity, or disaster struck them, would say, "What an evil time!" attributing those events to time and reviling it. In reality, however, the One who decreed those events was Allah. Therefore, reviling time in this sense is, in reality, directed toward Allah, which is why such speech was prohibited.
From the Scholars:
- Al-Tabari (may Allah have mercy on him) said regarding the verse (45:24):
("-and nothing destroys us except time.") It was mentioned that this verse was revealed because the polytheists used to say that time and the passing of ages destroyed them. They would then revile time, believing it to be the cause of their destruction. Allah informed them that He alone causes death and destruction, not time, and that they possessed no knowledge of what they claimed.
- Al-Baghawi (may Allah have mercy on him) likewise said:
The Arabs would habitually blame and revile time whenever calamities befell them because they attributed their hardships to it. They would say, "The blows of time struck them," or "Time destroyed them." Thus, by attributing those events to time, they were in reality reviling the One who truly decreed them, namely Allah. Therefore, they were prohibited from reviling time.
From the Scholars:
- Ibn Qutaybah (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
“Allah, the Mighty and Majestic, narrated concerning the people of Jahiliyyah that they used to attribute Allah’s decrees and actions to time. He said: ‘And they say, “There is nothing but our worldly life. We die and we live, and nothing destroys us except time.”’ [Surat al-Jathiyah 45:24] So the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said: Do not revile time when calamities befall you, and do not attribute them to it, for Allah, the Mighty and Majestic, is the One who caused that to befall you, not time. If you revile the true Doer, then the revilement falls upon Allah, the Mighty and Majestic. Do you not see that when one of them is afflicted by a calamity, or a disaster in his wealth, child, or body, and he reviles the one who did that to him while imagining it to be time, the one actually being reviled is Allah, the Mighty and Majestic.”
- Al-Kirmani (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
"His statement, 'I am ad-Dahr,' means: I am the One who controls time, or the Owner of time, or the One who alternates it and disposes of it. This is why He says, 'In My Hand are the night and the day.' The Arabs used to attribute calamities to time, and they fell into two groups: The first were the Dahriyyah, who did not believe in Allah and would say, 'Nothing destroys us except time.' The second group believed in Allah, but they considered it inappropriate to attribute hardships and calamities to Him, so they attributed them to time instead. Both groups used to revile time, saying, 'What a miserable time!' So Allah said to them: Do not revile it on the assumption that it is the one who acts, for Allah is the true Doer. If you revile the one who brought these hardships upon you, then your revilement returns to Allah. Thus, the meaning of 'I am ad-Dahr' is: I am the One who controls time. The wording was abbreviated for the sake of brevity while conveying the broader meaning."
From the Scholars:
- Al-Khattabi (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
"Its meaning is: I am the Owner of time and the One who manages the affairs which people attribute to time. Therefore, whoever reviles time because he believes it is the one that brings about these events has, in reality, directed his revilement toward his Lord, Who is the true Doer of them."
From the Scholars:
- Imam al-Nawawi (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
"The meaning of 'Indeed, Allah is ad-Dahr' is: Allah is the One who brings about calamities and events and is the Creator of all that exists. And Allah knows best."
From the Scholars:
- Shaykh Muhammad ibn Salih al-'Uthaymin (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
"Time is not one of the Names of Allah, the Most High. Whoever claims that it is has erred for two reasons. The first reason is that Allah's Names are all Most Beautiful. They represent the highest degree of beauty and perfection, and every one of His Names carries a meaning of complete excellence. Therefore, you will never find among Allah's Names a name that is merely a noun without conveying a perfect meaning. The word ad-Dahr (time) is simply a noun referring to periods of time and carries no such meaning. The second reason is that the wording of the hadith itself refutes this interpretation, because Allah says: 'I alternate the night and the day.' The night and the day are time itself. So how could the thing being alternated be the very One who alternates it?"
- Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyyah (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
"His statement, 'I am ad-Dahr,' means: I am the One who controls time, for time itself has no power to act. Rather, Allah alone is the true Doer. The hadith does not mean that ad-Dahr is one of the Names of Allah, because time is the created passage of time, and time itself is created."
Second: Is It Permissible to Address the Night or Time? Addressing the night, the day, one's home, the wind, and similar things is well known in Arabic speech, both in classical and later poetry. It is one of the recognized rhetorical styles of the Arabic language. Among their expressions are: • "O night." • "O time." • "O era." • "O home." If the intention is merely to portray one's condition or express the severity of grief or sorrow, without believing that the night hears or that time possesses any power to act, then this falls under the rhetorical style of the Arabic language.
From the Qur'an:
- [Surat Hud 11:44]
“O earth! Swallow up your water. And O sky! Withhold ˹your rain˺.”
This is an address directed to the earth and the sky by Allah's command, and it is one of the well-known styles of the Arabic language.
Likewise, the poet said: "O long night, will you not come to an end?" "ألا أيها الليل الطويل ألا انجلي" The scholars did not object to this as a linguistic style in and of itself. Third: When Does This Become Prohibited? It becomes prohibited if it includes any of the following: • Reviling time. • Objecting to Allah's decree and predestination. • Attributing events and actions to time itself. • Believing that time itself brings about good or evil. • Addressing time in a manner of seeking help from it or asking it to fulfill one's needs. So, "Time is not the one that acts. Rather, Allah, Glorified and Exalted, is the true Doer. Therefore, whoever reviles time has, in reality, reviled the One who brought these matters about, namely Allah, the Mighty and Majestic." For this reason: It is not permissible to revile time, because Allah is the One who controls it. Fourth: Is "Time" Meant to Refer to Allah? This is an incorrect understanding. The hadith: "I am ad-Dahr." does not mean: "I am time." Rather, it means: "I am the Lord of time, its Controller, and the One who disposes of it." For this reason, the leading scholars of Ahl al-Sunnah unanimously agreed that: • Time is created. • It is not one of the Names of Allah. • Allah is the Creator of time. Furthermore: Time is not one of Allah's Names because it does not contain a meaning of beauty and perfection. Fifth: Do These Poems Fall Under the Same Ruling as the Poem Ya Taybah? The answer is: not necessarily. Each poem is judged according to its intended meaning. If it contains: • Calling upon other than Allah. • Seeking help from other than Allah. • Requesting from someone that which none but Allah is able to provide. Then it takes the ruling appropriate to its particular content. As for merely saying: "O era of deadly silence..." or: "O night of heavy sorrow..." or: "O time, have you forgotten the Muslim?" Such expressions are not judged merely by their wording. Rather, one must look at what the speaker intends. If they are simply literary expressions used to portray a particular state or emotion, without containing anything contrary to the Shariah, then they do not fall under the category of calling upon other than Allah, nor do they come under the ruling of the poem Ya Taybah from this perspective. Final Answer: • Addressing the night or time as a purely rhetorical style is permissible, provided it is free from any corrupt belief. • It is forbidden to revile time or object to Allah's decree and predestination, because Allah alone is the Controller of time. • The Prophet's ﷺ statement, "I am ad-Dahr," does not mean that Allah is time. Rather, it means that He is the Creator, Controller, and Disposer of time. • Not every poem that addresses time or the night should be treated like the poem Ya Taybah. Rather, each case is judged according to its intended meaning, for rulings are based upon intentions and meanings, not merely upon words.
And Allah knows best.
← Back to QuestionsRelated Answers
Reconciling the Hadiths About Allah’s Descent and Saying He Descends at Sunset
I know that there are hadiths saying that Allah descends to the lowest heaven in the last third of the night, but there is a hadith in Sahih Muslim that says that Allah descends after a third of the night has passed. How can these be reconciled? And also, if someone says that Allah descends in the evening or at sunset to the lowest heaven, is that a statement of disbelief, since this was not mentioned by the Prophet ﷺ in any hadith? I am trying to learn about Islam, and Allah has blessed you with knowledge, so please help me.
The Meaning of the saying: “If Following Ahmad Makes One a Wahhabi…”
What is the meaning of the statement: "If following Ahmad makes one a Wahhabi, Then I openly admit that I am a Wahhabi." Who is meant by the word "Ahmad"? Is it Ahmad ibn Hanbal, Muhammad ﷺ, Muhammad ibn ʿAbd al-Wahhab, or someone else?
Do Allah’s Attributes Have a Limit Known Only to Him?
اَلسَلامُ عَلَيْكُم Sheikh i want ask a question , please don't judge me . I am asking because saitan is giving me waswasa. And I want prevent it so I am asking --- ibn Taymiyyah underlined in his books Dar' At-Ta‘aarudh and Bayaan Talbees Al-Jahmiyyah that Allaah is beyond the limits that we know but has a limit that only He knows. So my question is does Allaah's power, mercy and attributes has limit that only he knows? I don't want to ask this , but bcz of whisper i asking. pls answer. I beleive Allaah is free from al imperfection.
Do All of Allah’s Names Indicate His Attributes, and What Is the Ruling on Giving Allah’s Unique Attributes to Creation?
Do from every name of Allaah , we get a attribute of Allaah ? And what's the rulling if someone give a attribute of Allaah which is only for him to someone other than him?