Judging by Other Than What Allah Revealed and Applying Man-Made Laws

Question: What is meant by “judging by other than what Allah revealed”? Does it mean: If a person inherits according to a man-made civil law that contradicts what came in Islam? Or if a man is deliberately and unjustly killed, and the ruling for the killer is life imprisonment is this also considered judging by other than what Allah revealed, since the Islamic ruling in this case is blood-money or qiṣāṣ (retaliation)? And also: If a Muslim ruler judges that a thief (and the act is considered theft in Islam) be imprisoned, is this ḥarām because it is not a prescribed Islamic ḥadd punishment? Or is it permissible for the ruler to do so?

Summary:

Inheritance by civil law → Judging by other than what Allah revealed, with details based on belief. Deliberate murder judged with life imprisonment → Judging by other than what Allah revealed, with details based on belief. Thief sentenced to prison instead of ḥadd → If conditions of the ḥadd are not complete → taʿzīr is allowed. If the ḥadd is replaced by a man-made law despite being fully applicable → judging by other than what Allah revealed, and: Major disbelief if from belief in superiority of man-made law. Minor disbelief if while acknowledging Allah’s law.

Answer:

In the name of Allah, all praise is due to Allah, and may Peace and Blessings be upon the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ)

The meaning of “judging by other than what Allah revealed”

Judging by other than what Allah revealed means that the ruler, judge, or law-maker intentionally abandons Allah’s law and replaces it with laws, opinions, or desires, while Allah’s ruling exists for that matter.

From the Qur'an:

  • Surah al-Mā’idah (5:45) Surah al-Mā’idah (5:47) Surah al-Mā’idah (5:44)
    “Whoever does not judge by what Allah has revealed — they are the disbelievers.” “they are the wrongdoers.” “…they are the defiantly disobedient.”

From the Salaf:

  • Ibn ʿAbbās (may Allah be pleased with them both) interpreted the first verse and said:
    “It is disbelief less than disbelief,”

    if it is not out of rejection but is a sin and wrongdoing. Thus, judging by other than what Allah revealed may be major disbelief or minor disbelief depending on intention and belief.

1— A person inheriting according to a civil law that contradicts Islamic law Yes, this is judging by other than what Allah revealed, because Allah has clarified the shares of inheritance in detail, and they must not be changed. However: If he believes that the civil law is better than Allah’s ruling → this is major disbelief (kufr akbar). If he applies it due to desire, pressure, or habit while believing that Allah’s ruling is the truth → this is minor disbelief (kufr aṣghar) and a great sin and injustice.

From the Qur'an:

  • Surah An-Nisā’ 4:11
    “As an obligation from Allah. Indeed Allah is Knowing, Wise.”

    And He clarified that altering the prescribed shares is injustice and aggression. Deliberate murder for which the ruling is life imprisonment instead of qiṣāṣ or blood-money Yes, this is also judging by other than what Allah revealed, because Allah has decreed qiṣāṣ in cases of deliberate killing, or forgiveness with blood-money.

From the Qur'an:

  • Surah Al-Baqarah 2:178
    “O you who believe, prescribed for you is qiṣāṣ regarding the killed.”

    But the same detailed distinction applies: Whoever replaces Allah’s ruling believing the replacement is superior → this is major disbelief. Whoever replaces it out of desire or due to a man-made system while acknowledging Allah’s ruling is the truth → this is minor disbelief, and involves wrongdoing and sin. f a Muslim ruler sentences a thief to imprisonment instead of applying the ḥadd This case differs. The punishment for theft is an Islamic ḥadd clearly stated:

From the Qur'an:

  • Surah Al-Mā’idah 5:38
    “As for the male thief and the female thief cut their hands.”

    But the scholars stated that the ruler may apply taʿzīr (discretionary punishment such as imprisonment) when: The conditions of the ḥadd are not fulfilled (such as shubhah/doubt, lack of security around the stolen item, general poverty, or failure to meet the required minimum amount), Or if applying the ḥadd will lead to a greater harm; then the ruler may use taʿzīr for the protection of society. However: If all the conditions of the ḥadd are fulfilled and the ruler replaces it with a man-made law out of rejection of Allah’s law → major disbelief. But if he replaces it while acknowledging Allah’s ruling, but due to state laws or mistaken judgment → minor disbelief and wrongdoing. Taʿzīr (like imprisonment) is Islamically allowed in cases where the conditions of the ḥadd are not met. But replacing a complete ḥadd with another law is judging by other than what Allah revealed, and: It is major disbelief if accompanied by a belief that the man-made law is better. It is minor disbelief if done while recognizing Allah’s law. Ahl al-Sunnah distinguish and do not generalize: Judging by other than what Allah revealed is major disbelief when it involves: Denial, Believing that other than Allah’s law is better, Or equal to it, Or believing that Allah’s ruling is unsuitable for the time. It is minor disbelief when: The ruler acknowledges Allah’s ruling but judges otherwise due to fear, desire, weakness, or worldly motives.

From the Scholars:

  • Ibn Taymiyyah said:
    “When he judges by other than what Allah revealed while knowing that he is disobeying Allah, then he is a wrongdoer, sinner.”

And Allah knows best.

← Back to Questions