Ruling on Abortion Due to Social Hardship and Divorce Before Four Months

Question: I respectfully request a fatwa, as the matter is urgent. My brother’s daughter was married four months ago, and one of the conditions of the marriage contract was independent housing. They agreed to this condition. After four months of marriage, the woman became pregnant. After the pregnancy, her husband and his family decided that she must live with them. The situation escalated to the point that they took the woman and all her belongings to her parents’ home because she refused. Shaykh, their final position is that she must live with them, and they will not go back on this. The woman’s family wants a divorce. The pregnancy is one month and two weeks old. May Allah bless you. Is it permissible to terminate the pregnancy at one month and two weeks, knowing that the harm is not medical. The harm is in her living situation, because she is in a state of divorce, and this fetus, which is one month and two weeks old, will complicate her life. She will not be able to give the child to her ex husband because she is the mother, and no one will propose to her or marry her because she has a child. This does not permit aborting the fetus.

Summary:

It is not permissible to terminate the pregnancy when it is one month and two weeks old merely due to social harm, fear of the future, or the occurrence of divorce, as long as the harm is not medical and does not pose a certain threat to the mother’s life. Terminating the pregnancy in this situation is prohibited according to the majority of scholars.

Answer:

First: The Ruling on Abortion Before the Soul Is Breathed

A fetus at one month and two weeks is within the stage before the soul is breathed into it. The soul is breathed into the fetus after four months.

Despite this, the majority of jurists from the Mālikī, Shāfiʿī, and Ḥanbalī schools, and many from the Ḥanafī school, agree that abortion is prohibited except for a legitimate Shar‘i excuse.

The scholars stated:

The fetus is sacred from the moment the nutfah is formed. Although the prohibition before the soul is breathed is lighter than after, it is not permissible without necessity.

Second: Is the Mentioned Harm a Legitimate Shar‘i Excuse The harm mentioned in the question is: Social harm, Fear of life becoming difficult, Fear of not being able to marry in the future, The fact that the fetus will remain with her after divorce. These are not necessities that permit abortion according to scholarly consensus, because: The necessity that permits abortion is a real threat to the mother’s life or a severe and confirmed medical harm. Psychological or social harm, or fear of the future, does not make the prohibited permissible. The scholars said: It is not permissible to take a potential life for a presumed benefit.

Third: The Responsibility of the Husband and His Family What the husband and his family did by violating the condition of independent housing is a Shar‘i violation, because: A condition in the marriage contract, if it does not contradict the Sharīʿah, must be fulfilled. The woman has the right to independent housing if she stipulated it. However, the wrongdoing of the husband does not permit aborting the fetus, because the fetus is an independent soul with no sin.

Fourth: Divorce Does Not Permit Abortion The occurrence of divorce, the expectation of divorce, or the fear that it will make future marriage difficult is not a Shar‘i excuse. Islam did not make poverty, loneliness, or fear of people a justification for taking a life. Allah تعالى says:

From the Qur'an:

  • Surah Al-Isra 31
    "Do not kill your children for fear of poverty."

Aborting the fetus at one month and two weeks is prohibited in this case. It is not Islamically permissible unless trustworthy physicians determine that continuing the pregnancy poses a confirmed threat to the mother’s life. What is required is patience, seeking her Shar‘i rights from the husband, or pursuing annulment or divorce if necessary, without violating the right of the fetus. We ask Allah to relieve her distress, mend her hardship, grant her and her child relief and a way out, and guide the husband and his family to justice and fairness.

And Allah knows best.

← Back to Questions