What Is The Ruling On Repeating After A Recorded Adhan If You Are Unable To Hear The Masjid?
Question: Assalam O Alaikum Sheikh, I live in the west and cannot hear adhan from my house. I’ve a clock in home that gives adhans on the time of adhan. Do I have to repeat after this type of adhan when I hear from it and make Dua after this adhan? JazakAllah Khairan
Summary:
If the clock merely plays a recorded adhan when the prayer time begins, then it is not prescribed for you to repeat after it or to recite the supplication that is reported after the adhan. This is because the prophetic narrations attach these acts to hearing the muadhdhin, and a recording is not a real adhan; rather, it is simply a replay of a previously recorded voice. However, if the adhan is being called live by a muadhdhin (even if it is transmitted through a live broadcast), then it is recommended for you to repeat after him, then send prayers upon the Prophet ﷺ, and then recite the supplication for al-Wasilah.
Answer:
Firstly: From the Sunnah
From the Sunnah:
- Narrated by Muslim.Abdullah bin Amr رضي الله عنه reported that the Prophet ﷺ said:
"When you hear the muadhdhin, then say the same as he says. Then send prayers upon me, for whoever sends one prayer upon me, Allah will send ten prayers upon him. Then ask Allah to grant me al-Wasilah, for it is a rank in Paradise that is befitting only for one servant from among the servants of Allah, and I hope that I will be that servant. Whoever asks Allah to grant me al-Wasilah will be entitled to my intercession."
This hadith makes the ruling dependent upon hearing the muadhdhin, meaning the person who is actually calling the adhan.
Secondly: Statements of the Scholars 1. The adhan played from a recording device, over the radio, or broadcast from one location to the rest of the mosques through electronic equipment is an innovated practice.
From the Scholars:
- The scholars of the Permanent Committee were asked:
Is the adhan for the obligatory prayers a Sunnah, and what is the ruling on using a recording of the adhan if the muadhdhins are not proficient in calling it? They replied: The adhan is a communal obligation (fard kifayah), in addition to being an announcement of the beginning of the prayer time and a call to the prayer. Therefore, it is not sufficient, when the prayer time begins, to play an adhan that was previously recorded. Rather, in every place where the prayer is established, the Muslims must appoint someone among themselves who is able to call the adhan properly when the prayer time begins.
- Shaykh Abd al-Aziz bin Abdullah bin Baz رحمه الله Shaykh Abd al-Razzaq Afifi رحمه الله Shaykh Abdullah bin Ghudayyan رحمه الله They were also asked:
I have heard that in some Muslim countries, people record the adhan of the Two Sacred Mosques onto a cassette tape, then place the radio in front of the loudspeaker so that it gives the adhan instead of the muadhdhin. Is the prayer valid? Please provide evidence from the Quran and the Sunnah, along with a brief explanation. They replied: It is not sufficient, for the prescribed adhan of the obligatory prayers, to play the adhan from a recorded tape. Rather, the obligation is that the muadhdhin himself should call the adhan for the prayer, because it has been authentically established that the Prophet ﷺ commanded that the adhan be called, and the basic principle regarding a command is that it indicates obligation.
- The Islamic Fiqh Council of the Muslim World League also resolved, during its ninth session held in Makkah in 1406 AH, the following:
It is not sufficient to broadcast the adhan in the mosques at the beginning of the prayer time by means of a recording device or the like. This does not fulfill the prescribed adhan, nor is it permissible for the performance of this act of worship. Rather, the Muslims must ensure that the adhan is called for every prayer time in every mosque, just as the Muslims have continuously practiced from the time of our Prophet Muhammad ﷺ until the present day.
- 2. Shaykh Muhammad bin Salih al-Uthaymin رحمه الله said:
If the adhan is recorded and is not an actual adhan being called at that time, then he should not respond to it, because it is not a real adhan. The person did not raise his voice with it at the time he was commanded to do so. Rather, it is merely something being heard from a previous adhan. Although we have some reservation regarding the expression "raising the adhan," we prefer that it be said, "So-and-so called the adhan," rather than, "He raised the adhan."
- 3. Shaykh Abd al-Aziz bin Baz رحمه الله said:
The adhan played from a recording is not an adhan that one follows. Rather, responding is only for the muadhdhin who is actually calling the adhan. However, if the adhan is live, then it should be answered.
The Ruling on a Clock That Plays the Adhan If the clock in the home plays a recorded adhan when the prayer time begins, then it is not considered a legislated adhan. Therefore: It is not Sunnah to repeat after it as though it were a muadhdhin. The supplication reported after the adhan is not established in this case as a Sunnah connected to that recording. However, if you hear a live adhan from a mosque (even through a live broadcast), then the Sunnah is to respond to the muadhdhin, send prayers upon the Prophet ﷺ, and then recite the supplication for al-Wasilah. Conclusion: The adhkar prescribed for responding to the muadhdhin and the supplication after the adhan are connected to an adhan that is actually called by a muadhdhin. They do not apply to recordings played from clocks, mobile phones, or other electronic devices, because these are not legislated adhans; rather, they are merely replays of a previously recorded voice. This is the view of the Permanent Committee, Shaykh Ibn Baz رحمه الله, and Shaykh Ibn Uthaymin رحمه الله.
And Allah knows best.
← Back to QuestionsRelated Answers
Praying at the Mosque When It Is 1.3 km Away and Parents Prevent It
I have a mosque about 1.3 km from my home by walking. Must I pray all the prayers in that mosque if I have no work? And if it is obligatory, what should I do if my parents refuse to let me go?
A Mosque in London Established ʿIsha Before the Published Time: What Is the Correct Ruling?
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته. Sheikh, I was recently in a masjid in London and the prayer time in the masjid for Isha prayer was 10:40PM. My mosque stood up and started praying at 10:30PM (10 minutes before the starting time of isha prayer). After the prayer ended, i asked a few general people from the followers about this and someone mentioned that they do this often here because they believe that the isha time is inaccurate and if it was truly accurate, we would be praying at 12Am so he said its allowed to pray isha early and that the religion is easy. What is the correct stance on this and should i continue praying at this mosque? Jazakallah khair.