Seeking Help from Angels and Others
Question: Abdullah ibn Ahmad ibn Hanbal narrated: I heard my father say: “I performed five Hajj pilgrimages: two riding and three walking, or three riding and two walking. I got lost in one of those Hajj journeys while walking, so I kept saying: ‘O servants of Allah, guide me to the way.’ I continued doing that until I found the path,” or something to that effect. It is also narrated in another report in Shu‘ab al-Iman that Ibn Abbas said the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said: “Indeed Allah has angels other than the protectors who record every leaf that falls. So if one of you finds a wilderness on earth, let him call: ‘Help me, O servants of Allah, may Allah have mercy on you.’” Narrated by al-Bazzar, through Hatim ibn Isma‘il, from Usama ibn Zayd, who said: Aban ibn Salih told me, from Mujahid, from Ibn Abbas. Is this hadith authentic or weak? And if it is authentic, what type of seeking help from angels is permissible, and what type is not? Some scholars say it is impermissible, while others say it is permissible.
Summary:
Ask only Allah for what only He can do (life, death, provision, guidance, forgiveness). Seeking help from creatures is permissible for what they are capable of, provided they are alive, present, and capable. The hadith is mauquf on Ibn Abbas meaning it is the statement of ibn Abbas not the statement of the Prophet (ﷺ) and relates to asking angels for guidance in the wilderness, not invoking dead or absent persons.
Answer:
In the name of Allah, all praise is due to Allah, and may Peace and Blessings be upon the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ)
From the Sunnah:
- Al-Bazzar (4922)Narrated Usama ibn Zayd al-Laythi, from Aban ibn Salih, from Mujahid, from Ibn Abbas, as a mauquf statement (attributed to Ibn Abbas):
“Indeed Allah has angels on earth besides the protectors, who record what falls from the leaves of trees. So if one of you encounters a wilderness on earth, let him call: ‘Help me, O servants of Allah.’”
Al-Bazzar said: “We do not know of this wording being narrated from the Prophet ﷺ except through this chain.” (Musnad al-Bazzar 11/181)
From the Scholars:
- (Al-Mawqizah p.52)
This hadith has two weaknesses: Its reliance on Usama ibn Zayd al-Laythi, who is a narrator about whom scholars differ. Some consider him reliable, some weak. Ahmad said: “If you study his hadiths, you will notice some unknowns.” (Al-Kamil fi Du‘afa’ al-Rijal 2/76). Al-Dhahabi described him as: “Trustworthy, but cautious; Yahya al-Qattan differed on him; Ahmad said: ‘He is nothing’; al-Nasa’i said: ‘He is not strong’; Ibn ‘Adi said: ‘No harm in him.’” (Al-Mughni fi al-Du‘afa’ 1/66). Also in Taqrib al-Tahdhib: “Trustworthy, cautious.” The narrators from Usama ibn Zayd differ in this hadith. Some narrated it as a marfu‘ (from the Prophet ﷺ), some as mauquf (from Ibn Abbas). Hatim ibn Isma‘il alone narrated it as marfu‘ in al-Bazzar (4922). Four others narrated it from Usama as mauquf: Abdullah ibn Farukh (Shu‘ab al-Iman 1/325) Ruh ibn ‘Abadah (Shu‘ab al-Iman 10/140) Ja‘far ibn ‘Awn (Shu‘ab al-Iman 10/140) Abu Khalid al-Ahmar (Al-Musannaf 6/91) They all reported it as Ibn Abbas’ statement, which is stronger because their narrators are more reliable. Imam al-Shafi‘i said: “The many are more trustworthy than the one.” (Ikhtilaf al-Hadith p.177). Al-Dhahabi also said: “Even if a trustworthy person narrated it with a chain, or left it as mauquf, the measure is what the majority of the reliable transmitters agreed upon.”
Thus, the correct view, if we accept it, is that it is Ibn Abbas’ statement, not the Prophet’s ﷺ. Al-Bayhaqi said: “This is mauquf on Ibn Abbas, practiced by the righteous scholars for its reliability.” (Al-Adab, p.269).
Regarding seeking help (Istighatha): The key principle is: asking anyone other than Allah for what only Allah can do is shirk. Seeking help from a creation is permissible under four conditions: The one being asked must be alive. Present. Capable of helping. It is believed that they are the means, and Allah is the ultimate cause. Asking a creation for something within their power is not shirk. The hadith mentioned refers to angels who are alive, performing their duties, placed by Allah to guide the lost. Asking their help in guiding the lost is permissible because they are capable of it. It is entirely different from asking a dead or absent person to: Heal the sick Provide sustenance Facilitate childbirth Grant mercy or wellbeing These are only within Allah’s power.
From the Scholars:
- (Majmu‘ al-Fatawa 1/103, 1/329, 1/344, 1/370)
“Seeking help (istighatha) is asking for relief, like seeking assistance (istinsar) is asking for support, or seeking aid (isti‘ana) is asking for help. One asks creation for what they are capable of, as Allah said… What only Allah can do should only be asked from Allah.”
- Shaykh Salih al-Shaikh clarified:
“The hadith does not permit asking the dead or others; it is specifically about asking living angels to guide the lost. Anyone claiming it allows calling a specific person by name is lying.”
And Allah knows best.
← Back to Questions