What Is Considered a Good Omen, and Is Feeling Optimistic a Permissible Fa'l?

Question: It is reported from the Prophet ﷺ that he said, “There is no contagion and no bad omen, and I like optimism.” It was said, What is optimism? He said, “A good word.” And in the narration of Abu Hurayrah, may Allah be pleased with him, in Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī, “There is no bad omen, and the best of it is optimism.” It was said, What is optimism? He said, “A righteous word that one of you hears.” So what is considered good optimism, glad tidings? And if a person sees something that brings joy to his heart and he says to himself, perhaps Allah will make the matter easy for me, is this considered permissible optimism? And what is the correct belief regarding optimism and glad tidings according to the righteous predecessors?

Summary:

Good optimism is legislated and beloved in Islam. It is everything that brings hope and good expectation of Allah into the heart, such as a good word or a positive meaning that settles in the heart, without attachment to causes and without believing that it has independent effect. If a Muslim feels comforted by something he sees or hears and says to himself, perhaps Allah will make it easy, while the heart relies upon Allah alone, then this is permissible optimism and not the forbidden bad omen.

Answer:

First: The foundation of optimism in the Sunnah

It is established from the Prophet ﷺ in the two authentic collections that he said:

From the Sunnah:

  • Sahih al-Bukhari 5756Narrated Anas:
    The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "No 'Adwa (no contagious disease is conveyed to others without Allah's permission), nor Tiyara, but I like the good Fal, i.e., the good word."

    And it is established from Abu Hurayrah, may Allah be pleased with him, in Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī:

From the Sunnah:

  • Sahih al-Bukhari 5754Narrated Abu Huraira:
    I heard Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) saying, "There is no Tiyara, and the best omen is the Fal." They asked, "What is the Fal?" He said, "A good word that one of you hears (and takes as a good omen).

    These two hadiths are the foundation showing that bad omens are negated and condemned, and optimism is good, beloved, and beneficial for the servant.

Second: The reality of good optimism Optimism is what a servant hears or sees that causes hope and good expectation of Allah to settle in his heart, without relying upon it and without attaching outcomes to it. Its origin is usually a good word that is heard, a good name, glad news, or a positive meaning that matches a person’s situation and causes optimism. For this reason, the scholars said that optimism is comfort for the soul and strengthening of hope, not attachment to causes and not belief in independent effect. Third: Examples of permissible good optimism From permissible optimism is that one who intends marriage hears a good word and says, perhaps Allah will make it easy, or that one seeking work hears a good name or good news and feels comforted, or that he sees something permissible and optimism settles in his heart regarding Allah, not regarding that thing itself. All of this is under one comprehensive condition, that he does not believe that this thing is an effective cause in itself, nor that success depends upon it. Fourth: The difference between optimism and bad omens The difference between them according to the Salaf is clear. Optimism strengthens hope, does not prevent proceeding, does not change decisions, and does not attach the heart to other than Allah. Bad omens create fear, prevent action, change decisions, and attach the heart to an imagined cause. For this reason they said, optimism encourages, and bad omens prevent, optimism is from Allah, and bad omens are from Shayṭān. Fifth: Is a passing thought of optimism considered optimism? If a person sees something permissible that brings joy to his heart and he says to himself, perhaps Allah will make the matter easy, without certainty, without reliance, and without believing in effect, then this is good and permissible optimism. This is because optimism is an action of the heart, not worship of a cause, and it is based on good expectation of Allah, not on what is seen or heard. Sixth: The belief of the Salaf regarding optimism The Salaf loved optimism, disliked bad omens, and made optimism follow reliance upon Allah, not replace it. Reliance upon Allah for them was dependence of the heart upon Allah while taking permissible means, and optimism was an added reassurance, nothing more. Good optimism is legislated and beloved. It is everything that places hope and good expectation of Allah into the heart, such as a good word or positive meaning, without attachment to it and without belief in independent effect. If a Muslim feels comforted by something permissible and says, perhaps Allah will make it easy, then this is permissible optimism according to the Salaf, as long as the heart relies upon Allah alone, without illusion or pessimism.

And Allah knows best.

← Back to Questions