Whispers About Whether Allah Can Lie and the Ruling on Such Thoughts
Question: I apologize for asking this question, and I know with certainty that Allah, Glorified and Exalted, does not say anything except the truth, and He is free from all deficiency. However, I am afflicted with obsessive whispers related to the question, can Allah lie. I seek Allah’s forgiveness and repent to Him from this thought, and I try to repel it and avoid it, but it persists with me. Fear comes into my heart, if I do not search for the answer and understand this matter, will Allah hold me accountable on the Day of Resurrection for that. I am exhausted by these whispers, and I believe that my Lord is free from every deficiency and flaw, so I ask you to clarify and explain the Islamic position regarding these thoughts. May Allah reward you with goodness.
Summary:
These thoughts are compulsive whispers that are not taken to account. Rather, they are from the plotting of Shayṭān. Allah, Glorified and Exalted, is absolutely free from lying, and lying is impossible with respect to Him, not due to inability, but due to His sacred perfection. You are not required to search into these whispers. Rather, what is legislated is to turn away from them and seek refuge in Allah. Allah will not hold you accountable for them as long as you hate them and believe in the transcendence of your Lord.
Answer:
In the name of Allah, all praise is due to Allah, and may Peace and Blessings be upon the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ)
First: The Reality of These Thoughts and Their Ruling in Islam
What comes to the heart in the form of compulsive questions regarding matters of creed, while hating them and feeling aversion to them, is from whispers, not from doubt nor belief. The Islamic law has indicated that the servant is not held accountable for them as long as he does not speak or act upon them.
From the Sunnah:
- Sahih al-Bukhari 5269Narrated Abu Huraira:
The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "Allah has forgiven my followers the evil thoughts that occur to their minds, as long as such thoughts are not put into action or uttered." And Qatada said, "If someone divorces his wife just in his mind, such an unuttered divorce has no effect.:
- Sahih Muslim 132aIt is narrated on the authority of Abu Huraira that some people from amongst the Companions of the Apostle (ﷺ) came to him and said:
Verily we perceive in our minds that which every one of us considers it too grave to express. He (the Holy Prophet) said: Do you really perceive it? They said: Yes. Upon this he remarked: That is the faith manifest.
Meaning, your hatred of them and your effort to repel them is proof of faith. Second: Declaring Allah Free from Lying Due to His Perfection Allah, Glorified and Exalted, does not say anything except the truth. Lying is deficiency and imperfection, and Allah is free from every deficiency.
From the Qur'an:
- (Qur’an 4:87)(Qur’an 4:122)(Qur’an 3:9)
“And who is more truthful than Allah in speech.” “And who is more truthful than Allah in statement.” “Indeed, Allah does not break His promise.”
These texts are decisive proofs that truthfulness is a confirmed attribute of perfection for Allah, and that lying is impossible for Him. Third: Explaining the Issue According to the Methodology of the Salaf The Salaf established a great principle, that the attributes of Allah are affirmed in a manner of perfection, and He is declared free from everything that contradicts perfection. So the statement of one who says, can Allah lie, is a corrupt question in itself, because ability does not relate to impossibilities. Lying is not an existent matter that can be conceived as perfection. Rather, it is pure deficiency, and impossibilities do not fall under ability. Just as it is not said, can Allah be incapable, or can He commit injustice, because incapacity and injustice are deficiencies. Declaring Allah free from them is the essence of His perfection, not a negation of ability.
Fourth: The Practical Islamic موقف Regarding These Whispers What is commanded Islamically is: Seeking refuge in Allah when they occur. Turning away from them and not engaging with them. Saying, I believe in Allah and His messengers, as the Prophet ﷺ instructed. Increasing in remembrance and obedience, for they weaken whispers. You are not required to research or investigate these thoughts. Rather, leaving them is the act of worship here. Fifth: Is the Servant Held Accountable for Them The servant is not held accountable for these whispers as long as: He hates them. He does not believe in them. He repels them and does not feel at ease with them. Rather, his patience and striving against them is rewarded, by the permission of Allah. Allah, Glorified and Exalted, is truthful in His speech and free from lying as a perfection of transcendence. These thoughts are whispers that do not harm faith and are not taken to account. What is required regarding them is turning away and seeking refuge, not searching and deepening. We ask Allah to expand your chest, remove the whispers from you, and keep you firm upon the truth.
And Allah knows best.
← Back to Questions