Do Ahlus Sunnah Affirm Limits and Boundaries for Allah as Ibn Taymiyyah Did?
Question: In his book Bayan Talbis al-Jahmiyyah, Ibn Taymiyyah affirms that Allah has limits and boundaries in the six physical directions: above, below, behind, in front, to the left, and to the right. Do Ahl al-Sunnah hold this view? What is your theological position regarding the statement of Ibn Taymiyyah?
Summary:
This issue requires careful clarification because many people quote statements from Ibn Taymiyyah in a fragmented manner or misunderstand his intended meaning. Ahl al-Sunnah wa al-Jama'ah affirm what Allah has affirmed for Himself of transcendence, exaltedness above His creation, and rising over the Throne. They believe that Allah is distinct from His creation and above His heavens, risen over His Throne in a manner befitting His majesty. As for the term "limit" (hadd), it is not a term found in the Qur'an or the Sunnah. Therefore, Ahl al-Sunnah neither affirm it unconditionally nor deny it unconditionally. Rather, they seek clarification regarding its intended meaning. If by "limit" it is meant that Allah is distinct from His creation, neither indwelling within them nor they within Him, then this is a correct meaning. However, if by it is meant that Allah is confined, encompassed, limited by, or surrounded by something, or that any part of His creation contains or encompasses Him, then this is false by consensus.
Answer:
First: What Do Ahl al-Sunnah Affirm?
Ahl al-Sunnah affirm what is established by the revealed texts.
From the Qur'an:
- [Surah Ta-Ha 20:5]
"The Most Merciful rose over the Throne."
- [Surah al-Mulk 67:16]
"Do you feel secure that He who is above the heaven..."
- Surah al-Nahl 16:50
"They fear their Lord above them."
From the Sunnah:
- Sahih MuslimMu'awiyah ibn al-Hakam al-Sulami (may Allah be pleased with him) reported:
The Prophet ﷺ said to a slave girl: "Where is Allah?" She replied: "In the heaven." He said: "Free her, for she is a believer."
The Salaf therefore affirmed the exaltedness of Allah and His being above His creation in a real sense.
Second: What Is Meant by "Limit" Among the Salaf? Reports have been narrated from some of the Salaf in which they used the term "limit," such as the statement of some of them: "He has a limit known only to Him." What they intended by this was to refute the Jahmiyyah, who claimed that Allah is neither inside the universe nor outside it, neither above it nor below it. The Salaf therefore intended to affirm the existence of the Lord and His distinctness from His creation. For this reason, Ibn Taymiyyah stated in numerous places that disputes concerning the term "limit" are, in many cases, merely disputes over wording, and that clarification must be sought regarding what is intended by the term. Third: Did Ibn Taymiyyah Say That Allah Has Limits in the Six Directions? This expression, stated in such absolute terms, is not an accurate representation of Ibn Taymiyyah's position. Rather, he affirmed that Allah is above the creation, distinct from His creation, and that created things have boundaries and limits at which they end. As for saying: "Allah has limits and boundaries above, below, in front, behind, to the right, and to the left." This expression is ambiguous and may suggest false meanings that Ibn Taymiyyah did not intend. Rather, Ibn Taymiyyah explicitly stated that Allah is greater than anything in His creation encompassing Him, and that the Throne neither confines Him nor contains Him. Fourth: What Is the Correct Theological Position? The position of Ahl al-Sunnah is: To affirm what Allah has affirmed for Himself. To believe in Allah's exaltedness above His creation. To believe that He is risen over His Throne in reality. To believe that He is distinct from His creation. To avoid engaging in newly introduced ambiguous terms unless their meanings are first clarified. To deny that anything encompasses Allah or confines Him from among His creation.
From the Salaf:
- Imam Malik ibn Anas (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
"The rising over the Throne is known, its manner is unknown, belief in it is obligatory, and asking about it is an innovation."
This is a foundational principle regarding all of the divine attributes.
Conclusion: It is not from the creed of Ahl al-Sunnah to say, in an unrestricted manner, that "Allah is limited by the six directions." Rather, their creed is that Allah is above His creation, risen over His Throne, distinct from His creation, and that nothing from His creation encompasses Him. As for the term "limit," it is an ambiguous term. If it is intended to mean the distinction between the Creator and the creation, then it is true. If it is intended to mean that Allah is confined, contained, or encompassed, then it is false. For this reason, the methodology of the Salaf was to seek clarification regarding ambiguous expressions and to refer them back to the meanings established by the revealed texts.
And Allah knows best.
← Back to QuestionsRelated Answers
Reconciling the Hadiths About Allah’s Descent and Saying He Descends at Sunset
I know that there are hadiths saying that Allah descends to the lowest heaven in the last third of the night, but there is a hadith in Sahih Muslim that says that Allah descends after a third of the night has passed. How can these be reconciled? And also, if someone says that Allah descends in the evening or at sunset to the lowest heaven, is that a statement of disbelief, since this was not mentioned by the Prophet ﷺ in any hadith? I am trying to learn about Islam, and Allah has blessed you with knowledge, so please help me.
The Meaning of “Letter” in the Belief That Allah Speaks With Sound and Letter
the creed of Ahl al-Sunnah is that Allah speaks with sound and letter. Can you please explain what is meant by “letter”? Is it one of Allah’s attributes? I suffer from satanic whispers.
Is the Verse “The Hand of Allah Is Above Their Hands” Taken Literally or Interpreted, and How Did the Salaf Understand It
Is the verse, “The Hand of Allah is above their hands” taken according to its apparent meaning, or is it interpreted, and how did the righteous predecessors understand it?
Whispers About Whether Allah Can Lie and the Ruling on Such Thoughts
I apologize for asking this question, and I know with certainty that Allah, Glorified and Exalted, does not say anything except the truth, and He is free from all deficiency. However, I am afflicted with obsessive whispers related to the question, can Allah lie. I seek Allah’s forgiveness and repent to Him from this thought, and I try to repel it and avoid it, but it persists with me. Fear comes into my heart, if I do not search for the answer and understand this matter, will Allah hold me accountable on the Day of Resurrection for that. I am exhausted by these whispers, and I believe that my Lord is free from every deficiency and flaw, so I ask you to clarify and explain the Islamic position regarding these thoughts. May Allah reward you with goodness.
The Salaf’s and Sheikh Ibn ‘Uthaymīn’s Position on Affirming Allah’s Elevation and Establishment on the Throne
اَلسَلامُ عَلَيْكُم Al-Qurtubi said “The first generation of the Salaf, may Allah be pleased with them, did not speak about denying the direction and they did not utter such a thing Ibn ‘Uthaymeen may Allaah have mercy upon him was asked about the ‘Uluww (aboveness) of Allaah and those who hold that Allaah does not exist in the six physical directions but rather only in the believer's heart. He replied -- As for their saying that Allaah does not exist in the six physical directions, this statement is generally false because it entails negating what Allaah has affirmed in relation to Himself... So what is Sheikh Uthaymeen trying to say.?. Can we say Arsh is is above all six direction and Allaah is above all six direction over Arsh ?? And does Arsh encompasses whole universe?? Please clarify this to me . It will be lot help. May Allaah bless you.
The Meaning of the Statement of Allah: “To Allah belong the East and the West, so wherever you turn, there is the Face of Allah”
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته . I have a question shiekh. What does the verse mean in surah baqarah verse 115 “To Allah belong the east and the west, so wherever you turn you are facing Allah. Surely Allah is All-Encompassing, All-Knowing.”. Many asharis and other misguided sects say that if you guys dont make ta’wil (interpretation) then you have to accept that allah is everywhere. Could you refute this. بارك الله فيك.
Are the Hadiths About the Lord Sitting on the Kursi and the Creaking Sound Authentic?
The questioner says, Some people gave me these two hadiths, and I would like to know, are they authentic or not? The first, A woman came to the Prophet ﷺ and asked him to supplicate to Allah to admit her into Paradise. The Prophet ﷺ magnified the Lord and said, “Indeed His Kursī encompasses the heavens and the earth, and He sits upon it, and there remains from it only the space of four fingers,” and he gestured with his fingers, “and it creaks like the creaking of a new saddle when it is mounted due to its weight.” This is mentioned in Bayān Talbīs al-Jahmiyyah, volume 3, page 261. The second, It is narrated from ʿUmar ibn al-Khaṭṭāb, may Allah be pleased with him, that a woman came to the Prophet ﷺ and said, Supplicate to Allah that He admits me into Paradise. He ﷺ said, “Indeed His Kursī encompasses the heavens and the earth, and when the Lord sits upon the Kursī a creaking sound is heard like the creaking of a new saddle due to its weight.” It has been said that this hadith was narrated by al-Bazzār, and that its narrators are the narrators of the Ṣaḥīḥ.
Is It Correct to Say: “Allah Is Above the East”?
We know that Allaah is above his Arsh. So if someone say "Allaah is above east " or Pointing to sky that "Allaah is above arsh above the what I have pointed with my finger. So is it valid or invalid statement? As someone is fixing a fixed direction for Allaah ?