Is It Permissible for Parents to Force a Girl to Marry Someone She Does Not Want, or Is Her Consent Required?

Question: Assalam u alaikum I wanted to ask if islam has made it fard(obligatory) for parents to marry their children or is it sunnah. Most of parents say that daughters do not have the right to speak for anything in their marriage and only parents can decide since children know nothing and parents always do the best for them , can children go against them and try to convince them to ask their children especially daughters that whether you want to get married or not and if you want to get married is the proposal we decided okay with you or not or the daughters should just listen to their parents and do nothing except crying, what does Allah and sunnah says about this?

Summary:

The parents do not have the right to force an adult son or daughter to marry, nor may they choose a husband for their daughter and then compel her to marry him while she dislikes him. Rather, the consent of both spouses is taken into consideration in the Shariah, and the Prophet ﷺ commanded that the virgin be asked for permission and that the previously married woman be consulted. Shaykh Ibn Baz رحمه الله said regarding the ruling on a guardian forcing a virgin or a previously married woman to marry: “A man does not have the right to force his daughter, whether she is a virgin or previously married, to marry.” As for a father bearing the expenses of his children’s marriages: if the son or daughter needs to marry, is unable to afford its expenses, and the father is financially capable, then according to a group of scholars, and this is the position of the Hanbali madhhab, arranging their marriage falls under obligatory maintenance and is not merely a Sunnah or a voluntary act. However, this does not mean that the father has the right to forcibly choose the husband or wife. There is a difference between the obligation to assist someone in marrying when there is a need and that person’s right to accept or reject the individual whom they will marry.

Answer:

First: Does a woman have the right to say, “I want this husband” or “I do not want him”?

Yes. This is a right established for her in the authentic Sunnah.

From the Sunnah:

  • Sahih Bukhari and MuslimAbu Hurayrah رضي الله عنه narrated that the Prophet ﷺ said:
    “A previously married woman is not to be married until she is consulted, and a virgin is not to be married until her permission is sought.” They said: “O Messenger of Allah, how is her permission known?” He ﷺ said: “That she remains silent.”

    The meaning of “she is consulted” is that her opinion and approval are sought. The meaning of “her permission is sought” is that the marriage contract is not concluded for her until her permission has been obtained. This hadith alone refutes the statement of those who say: “A daughter has no say regarding her marriage; rather, the entire decision belongs to her father and mother.” Rather, the guardian has an important role in marriage. He considers her best interests and searches for a righteous man, but he does not nullify her consent.

Second: What if the father chooses a man who is very righteous, but his daughter does not want him? It is not permissible to force her to marry him, even if the man is righteous.

From the Scholars:

  • Shaykh Ibn Baz رحمه الله said:
    “The guardian does not have the right to force a woman to marry, even if it is the most perfect of people. He does not have the right to force her. Rather, she has the choice.”
  • He also said:
    “If she refuses and says: ‘I do not want this man,’ she is not to be forced, and it is never permissible for her father to force her.”
  • He رحمه الله also said elsewhere:
    “Even if she remains unmarried, that is up to her; this is her right.”

    The fact that the father loves his daughter, wants what is best for her, and has more experience than she does means that he should advise her and explain matters to her. It does not mean that he may take away a right that the Shariah has given her.

Third: Did anything like this occur during the time of the Prophet ﷺ? Yes.

From the Sunnah:

  • It was narrated by al-Bukhari in his Sahih and by Abu Dawud.From Khansa bint Khidam رضي الله عنها
    It is reported from Khansa bint Khidam رضي الله عنها that her father married her off while she had previously been married and she disliked the marriage. She went to the Messenger of Allah ﷺ, and he annulled her marriage.

    It is also mentioned in Sahih al-Bukhari that a woman feared that her guardian would marry her off while she disliked it, so the story of Khansa was mentioned to her: the Prophet ﷺ annulled her marriage when her father married her off while she was unwilling. This is strong evidence that obedience to one’s parents does not mean that the father possesses the right to force his daughter to marry a man whom she does not want.

Fourth: Is there not an opinion among the jurists permitting a father to force his virgin daughter to marry? Yes. There is an old difference of opinion among the jurists concerning this matter. Some scholars held that a father may compel his virgin daughter to marry under certain conditions. Some scholars held this view and considered it permissible for him to marry off his virgin daughter without her permission because she may not fully know what is in her best interests. However, this opinion conflicts with the Sunnah and contradicts it, so it should not be relied upon.

From the Qur'an:

  • [Al-Ma’idah: 92]
    “Obey Allah and obey the Messenger.”
  • [An-Nur: 63]
    “So let those who oppose his command beware, lest a trial afflict them or a painful punishment afflict them.”
  • [An-Nisa: 59]
    “If you disagree over anything, refer it to Allah and the Messenger.”

    Therefore, it is not permissible for a believer to oppose the command of Allah and the command of His Messenger ﷺ because of the statement of any person, whoever that person may be. Other scholars held that it is not permissible to marry off an adult, rational woman without her consent.

The view regarded as strongest by verifying scholars such as Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyyah رحمه الله, and which was also chosen among contemporary scholars by Shaykh Ibn Baz رحمه الله and Shaykh Ibn Uthaymin رحمه الله, is that an adult virgin may not be forced to marry someone whom she does not want, due to the strength of the explicit hadiths requiring her permission. Fifth: May a daughter say to her father, “I do not want to get married at all”? With regard to the validity of the marriage contract and compulsion: yes. She may not be married off by force, and merely refusing marriage is not, in and of itself, disobedience to her parents.

From the Scholars:

  • Shaykh Ibn Baz رحمه الله was asked about a girl to whom righteous men proposed, but she said, “I do not want to get married.” He said:
    “Marriage requires the consent of both the wife and the husband... The son is not to be forced to marry once he is legally accountable, and likewise the daughter is not to be forced.”

    However, if she needs to marry and there is fear that she may fall into temptation, then she should be advised to marry and the virtues and benefits of marriage should be explained to her through advice and persuasion, not through compulsion.

Sixth: Is a father obligated to arrange the marriages of his sons and daughters? The matter requires detail. It does not mean that every father, as soon as his children reach adulthood, is obligated immediately to search for spouses for them regardless of whether they need marriage or not. Rather, if the son or daughter needs to marry, cannot afford the expenses of marriage, and the father is financially capable, the Hanbali jurists have stated that helping them preserve their chastity and arranging their marriage falls under obligatory maintenance.

From the Scholars:

  • Ibn Qudamah رحمه الله said:
    “The father must help his son preserve his chastity if his maintenance is obligatory upon him and the son needs assistance in preserving his chastity.”
  • Shaykh Ibn Uthaymin رحمه الله said:
    “The father is obligated to arrange his son’s marriage if the son needs to marry and does not have the means with which to marry.”

    Likewise, it has been mentioned that arranging marriage is included within the obligatory maintenance of a son or daughter who is unable to afford it when the conditions of maintenance and need are fulfilled.

Therefore, the issue cannot simply be stated as: “Arranging the marriages of one’s children is a Sunnah upon the parents,” without qualification, nor can it be said: “It is obligatory upon every parent to marry off every child as soon as they reach adulthood.” Rather, the ruling is connected to need, financial capability, and the obligation of maintenance. Seventh: Is it permissible for children to discuss this with their parents and try to convince them to ask the daughter? Yes. In fact, what they are requesting in this situation is in accordance with the Sunnah: that the woman be asked and that her consent regarding marriage in general and regarding the specific man be known. However, this should be done with good manners and gentleness, without raising one’s voice or behaving disrespectfully, in compliance with the statement of Allah تعالى:

From the Qur'an:

  • [Al-Isra: 23]
    “And speak to them a noble word.”

A person may therefore say to the father politely: “Father, you are the person most concerned about your daughter’s welfare, and the Prophet ﷺ commanded that a virgin’s permission be sought. So let us ask her and explain the qualities of the suitor to her. If she is pleased, the marriage can proceed, and if she is not pleased, we should not force her.” This is similar to what Shaykh Ibn Baz رحمه الله advised when a disagreement occurs: speaking kindly to the father, advising him, and seeking the assistance of people of knowledge and righteous relatives to advise him if he does not accept the advice. Conclusion: 1. It is not permissible to force an adult son to marry someone whom he does not want, nor to force a daughter to marry someone whom she does not want. 2. It is obligatory in the Shariah to seek a virgin’s permission regarding the specific husband, while a previously married woman must give her explicit consent, due to the statement of the Prophet ﷺ: “A previously married woman is not to be married until she is consulted, and a virgin is not to be married until her permission is sought.” 3. The father’s guardianship does not mean that he possesses the right to force his daughter. Rather, he should advise her, choose a suitable and compatible man for her, explain his good qualities to her, and then the marriage should take place with her consent. 4. If the son or daughter needs to marry, is unable to afford the expenses of marriage, and the father is financially capable, then according to a group of scholars, arranging the marriage falls under obligatory maintenance. 5. A daughter is not required to “remain silent, cry, and obey” if her family wants to marry her to someone she dislikes. Rather, she has the right to say, “I do not want him,” and this is not, in itself, disobedience to her parents, while she must still maintain good manners, dutifulness, and kind speech toward them.

And Allah knows best.

← Back to Questions

Related Answers

Approaching a Girl for Marriage the Right Way

If you find a girl you want to marry, how can you approach her in a halal way? Is it allowed to speak to her and ask her to give your phone number to her father?

Read full answer

Forced Marriages and Beating by Parents

I am a young woman who was forced by my parents to marry a young man without giving my consent to marry him. When I confronted them that I did not want to marry him, they beat me severely. My father and mother together with my two brothers beat me, they punched and strangled me until bruises appeared on my body and my eyes bled from the severity of the beating. Then they took me to the place of the marriage contract and threatened me to say “yes” in front of the sheikh who was conducting the contract. Out of fear I said “yes” at that moment. I could not complain to the government because I was afraid they would imprison my father or dismiss him from work and I did not want to cause him problems. I even contacted that young man and told him that my consent was not real. In this case, what should I do, and is this marriage valid in Islamic law, and is that young man guilty of fornication because he knows that my marriage to him was not with my approval and that my saying “yes” was only out of fear. I ask for your guidance and advice.

Read full answer

Marrying a Woman Who Wears the Hijab but Not the Niqab

Peace, mercy, and blessings of Allah be upon you. I have been actively searching for a righteous wife who adheres to the complete Islamic dress code, including the niqab, for about six months to a year. Despite my sincere efforts, I have found it difficult to find such a woman. I am physically and financially capable of marriage, praise be to Allah. Is it permissible for me to marry a woman who wears the jilbab and hijab only that is, modest clothing without the niqab if I cannot find one who wears the niqab?

Read full answer

Is It Permissible for a Woman to Live Alone and Remain Unmarried?

Ive grown up in an abusive and toxic household which took a giant negative effect from my health. I’ve been planning to live alone for a while now but heard negative opinions of it. As a girl, I have zero interest in marriage. Is it permissible for me to choose to live alone in a safe city?

Read full answer

Should a Young Muslim Prioritize Marriage or Education and Career?

I am 25 years old. I want to complete my graduation and build a career. At the same time, I feel sexual desire. Now I want to know: Which is a priority for me in Islam—marriage first or career first? What is the Shariah guidance in my situation?

Read full answer

What Should a Woman Do If Her Father Unjustly Delays Her Marriage and Rejects Righteous Suitors?

My father is delaying marriage for me and rejecting suitors with good religious backgrounds. He tells me that I need to finish my education first and that I can only get married later in my life . When I try to speak with him, he often gets extremely angry and paranoid, which is heightened because he takes a substance known to cause paranoia. Because of this, he doesn't take anything I say into consideration, so I usually just stay quiet. What should I do ?

Read full answer

Is It Permissible for a Woman to Look Up a Potential Suitor Online Before Marriage?

Assalamu alaykum. I have a question regarding looking into a potential suitor before marriage. If a man is a potential suitor, is it permissible for a woman to look him up online in order to see what he looks like and how he presents himself, before deciding whether she is interested in pursuing the proposal? I ask because the Prophet ﷺ encouraged a person who intended to marry someone to look at her, would this principle also apply to a woman looking at a potential male suitor? Additionally, would it be permissible for her to look at his public social media posts to learn more about his character, interests, and how he conducts/presents himself? For example, if he publicly posts things such as music, etc. as this could avoid avoiding unnecessarily pursuing a proposal JazakAllahu Khairun

Read full answer