Is It Permissible to Speak to Allah Internally Without Moving the Tongue?
Question: As salamu Alaykum I have a question regarding something related to the heart and thoughts. When a person is going through sadness, hardship, or any personal difficulty, they may sometimes speak to Allah inwardly in their mind—for example, expressing their feelings, worries, or problems to Allah without moving their tongue or making verbal du'a. My question is not about making du'a silently in the heart. Rather, I am specifically asking about having an internal conversation with Allah in one's thoughts, such as mentally saying, "O Allah, I am struggling," or speaking to Allah in one's mind about personal matters without uttering any words. Is this permissible
Summary:
Yes, it is permissible for a Muslim to privately converse with his Lord in his heart and to speak to Him inwardly about whatever worries, sorrows, or needs he has. Allah, the Exalted, knows every secret and what is even more hidden, and He knows what the soul whispers to itself. However, if one intends to make the legislated du'a established in the texts, then the more complete and better way is to make it with the tongue while the heart is present, because du'a is fundamentally from the category of speech and calling upon Allah. As for merely speaking to Allah inwardly and expressing one's dependence upon Him in the heart, there is no harm in that. Rather, it is among the righteous actions of the heart.
Answer:
First: Evidence from the Quran
From the Qur'an:
- (Surah Qaf 50:16)
"And We have already created man and know what his soul whispers to him, and We are closer to him than his jugular vein."
Allah, the Exalted, knows what is in His servant's heart even before he speaks.
- (Surah Ta Ha 20:7)
"And if you speak aloud, then indeed He knows the secret and what is even more hidden."
The commentators said that "the secret" refers to what a person conceals within himself, while "what is even more hidden" refers to what has not yet even crossed his mind.
- (Surah Al-A'raf 7:55)
"Call upon your Lord humbly and privately."
This verse indicates the legislation of making du'a quietly. However, the legislated du'a is made with spoken words while lowering one's voice, not merely through inward thoughts alone.
Second: Evidence from the Sunnah
From the Sunnah:
- Narrated by Al-Bukhari and Muslim.On the authority of Abu Hurairah رضي الله عنه, the Prophet ﷺ said:
"Indeed, Allah has pardoned my nation for what they say to themselves, so long as they do not act upon it or speak of it."
This hadith distinguishes between inner thoughts and spoken speech, indicating that what occurs within the heart is known to Allah.
- Narrated by Al-Bukhari and Muslim.In the Qudsi hadith, Allah says:
"Allah says: I am as My servant thinks of Me, and I am with him when he remembers Me. If he remembers Me within himself, I remember him within Myself..."
This indicates that remembrance of Allah with the heart is legislated and that Allah rewards a person for it.
Third: Statements of the Scholars
From the Scholars:
- 1. Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyyah رحمه الله said:
"The people are of four categories with regard to remembrance of Allah: The first is remembrance with both the heart and the tongue, and this is what has been commanded. The second is remembrance with the heart alone. If this is due to the inability of the tongue, then it is good. But if it is while one is able to use the tongue, then it is abandoning what is better. The third is remembrance with the tongue alone, whereby the person's tongue remains moist with the remembrance of Allah. The fourth is the absence of both, and this is the state of the losers."
His words indicate that remembrance with the heart is legislated, but combining both the heart and the tongue is more complete.
- 2. Shaykh Abdul Aziz ibn Baz رحمه الله:
He was asked: "Is there a reward for seeking forgiveness and remembering Allah with the heart?" He replied: "There is reward for remembering Allah with the heart. Allah is remembered with the heart, the tongue, and one's actions. As for seeking forgiveness, there is no seeking forgiveness with the heart alone. It is not called istighfar. A servant may repent to Allah in his heart and feel remorse, and this is called repentance. Istighfar is a request for forgiveness, and that is done with the tongue. What is in the heart is remorse for past sins, abandoning the sin, and having a sincere resolve not to return to it. If a person regrets the sin, firmly resolves in his heart not to return to it, and abandons it, then this is called repentance, not istighfar."
- He also said:
"Remembrance of Allah with the heart is legislated at all times and in every place."
- 3. Islam Question and Answer Fatwa:
"The prescribed adhkar, supplications, and legislated statements must be accompanied by movement of the tongue according to the majority of the scholars. As for mere reflection and inner thoughts, they are not considered du'a, although a person is rewarded for them insofar as they involve reflection and expressing one's need before Allah."
The Ruling on Making Du'a with the Heart Without the Tongue Is it permissible for a person to say within himself: "O Allah, I am exhausted." "My Lord, help me." "My Lord, You know my condition." "O Allah, I am sad." Without moving his tongue? The answer is: Yes, there is no harm in that, because Allah knows what is in the heart. This is an inward conversation with Allah and an expression of one's dependence upon Him. However, if a person wishes to attain the virtue of the legislated du'a mentioned in the texts, then it is better for him to move his tongue in supplication, even if only in a quiet voice, while his heart remains present. Conclusion: It is permissible for a Muslim to privately converse with Allah in his heart and to speak to Him inwardly about whatever worries, sorrows, and needs he has. Allah, the Exalted, knows every secret and what the hearts conceal, and He hears His servant's inward conversation. This is among the legislated actions of the heart, and there is no harm in it. However, if one intends the legislated du'a established in the Quran and the Sunnah, then the better and more complete practice is to supplicate with the tongue while the heart is present, because this is the way of the Prophets and is what is indicated by the textual evidence and the statements of the majority of the scholars.
And Allah knows best.
← Back to QuestionsRelated Answers
Three Ways Allah Responds to a Muslim’s Supplication
If I’ve been making dua for a long time and one of them gets accepted, does that mean Allah is answering my prayers or could it be a test from Him?
The Best Way to Make Duʿāʾ According to the Sunnah
What is the best way to make du‘āʾ so that it is answered according to the Sunnah?
Can a Person Stop or Combine Prayers Due to Severe Depression?
I suffer from severe depression, and I have reached a stage where I feel that prayer causes me suicidal thoughts, and supplication brings me panic attacks. I do not say this out of belittling the religion, but because of the intensity of distress and psychological pain that I am in. Is it permissible for me in this situation to temporarily stop performing the prayer, or at least is it permissible for me to combine the prayers, such as combining them at the time of ʿAṣr or Maghrib, due to this severe psychological condition? Please advise, may Allah bless you.
What Is the Cure for Severe Sadness Despite Maintaining Worship and Adhkar?
I have an issue that is causing me immense distress. I am a Sunni Salafi and a student of knowledge, all praise is due to Allah. I pray, fast, and avoid what is unlawful. I do not speak to women, listen to music, or trim anything from my beard. I am suffering from severe worry and sadness, to the point that sometimes I wish I could die. I have tried ruqyah, and all praise is due to Allah, whenever I perform ruqyah on myself, I feel well and relieved, and I do not experience that sadness. However, this only lasts for one day, then the worry and sadness return to the extent that I cannot even think about how to treat it. I do not neglect the morning and evening adhkar, the adhkar before sleep, or any of the daily remembrances. This sadness has prevented me from engaging in acts of worship and seeking knowledge. Every day I sit on my bed using my phone until night comes. What is the remedy, Shaykh? What should I do?